The mermaid has been stolen from the circus! The Thief hauls the stolen siren to a safe spot, then calls the Buyer to let him know the mermaid has been acquired and is ready for purchase. The mermaid wakes up during the phone call, and immediately starts screaming. The Thief freaks out, grabbing a rag soaked in a special formula made to knock the mermaid out. They briefly struggle, but the mermaid is no match for The Thief. She goes back under, and The Thief plays with her limp body to be sure she's out.