Lily Rader and Lily Adams are in the backyard playing catch. The girls have to test out the new girl, Athena Palomino, to see if she can make the cut for the softball team. When she finally arrives, the girls throw everything they got at her. They cringe as they watch her drop every ball that's thrown at her. What was Athena thinking? She stinks! She can't throw, she can't catch and she can't run. The girls have no idea what they're going to do with her. When Athena asks the girls if she made the team, the news is bleak. She can't run straight, she can barely hit the ball, she even broke one of their windows. The girls have no choice but to cut her. Athena is devastated; she wants nothing more than to be on the team and will do anything to make the cut.