Waking up one morning, Dusty tells Peppermint about a movie he was watching the previous night in which one of the characters was telling her husband about her past lovers. Hearing this made Dusty curious about the other cocks that Peppermint has had. Reluctant at first, Peppermint warms up to the idea of telling Dusty about her former partners, the size and shape of their cocks, how they fucked her and where they came. Thinking about Peppermint's tiny pussy being stretched in different ways excites Dusty. Peppermint stokes his hard cock under the covers, then proceeds to suck it. Taking off her clothes, Peppermint demonstrates to Dusty how she had been fucked a few different ways. While on top of him, she grabs a toy to tease her clit as they fuck until they both cum together.