First Time Pegging You We've talked about butt stuff and you've enjoyed cumming to my finger in your asshole, but we've never fulfilled your fantasy of having me peg you. I got horny and bought a new toy, something for me to peg you with, it's amazing. I show you the toy and talk about me filling your asshole while I play with your cock and rim you with my finger. Then you let me gently peg you in a loving and sensual way.