Gabbie Carter is secretly dating two girls, Eliza Ibarra and Lulu Chu, but knows that she can't string them along any further. She HAS to choose one to commit to, no matter how great they BOTH are. That's when she decides to call Eliza over to have a serious talk with her. Before Gabbie can say anything, they are interrupted by the doorbell, which confuses Gabbie. She excuses herself to answer the door and is shocked to see Lulu, who has shown up to give her a romantic surprise. As Gabbie flits between the bedroom with Eliza and the living room with Lulu, unable to keep her hands off them. How can she break up with EITHER of them now??