After months of his begging, a prude teen virgin (Lena Paul) finally agrees to have sex with her horny older boyfriend (Robby Echo) ... even without a condom. She awkwardly allows him to mount her and fuck her missionary, before turning her around to fuck her doggy style. As he is about to cum, the boyfriend doesn't pull out in time as he promised and creampies the girl. When she realizes what he's done, she gets upset and asks him to leave. Ashamed and nervous, she goes to clean herself up but, when she reaches down to her pussy and feels his cum dribbling out of her, something changes in her. Becoming transfixed, she rubs it into herself and plays with it in her fingers, before putting it in her mouth. She is shocked but also so intrigued by how good it feels to be filled up inside that she ends up touching herself. After masturbating for a few minutes, she decides that she wants to experience it again and she rushes over to the boyfriend's house. But when she gets there, his twin brother (Tyler Nixon) answers instead. The boyfriend isn't home. The girl decides to wait for the boyfriend to come home, but gets impatient and comes to the realization that she could always seduce the brother instead, especially since they look so similar. In the end, she gets the twin to fuck her and creampie her too, unable to control herself she leaves his house with cum dribbling down her leg, as she bumps into her boyfriend arriving home